Facing a lawsuit is a horrible and somewhat costly experience, whether it’s personal or business-related. Any small business can find themselves in this situation – even freelancers! Going through a lawsuit can be a very emotional time for everyone involved but the important thing is to keep your cool and react calmly.
The first thing you should do after receiving a lawsuit is to review it fully. Whether you hire outside counsel or use your internal legal department, you should seek legal advice – websites such as Lawbite can help with this if you run a small business.
The lawsuit should be checked for accuracy in the first instance
The lawyer will check the lawsuit for any errors that could give cause to dismiss the lawsuit and help you decide your next move. Tell your lawyer upfront if there is anything not mentioned in the suit that could come up later and discredit you. That way they can build a defence against it.
Importantly, do not try to communicate directly with the plaintiff; any communication should be via your lawyer to avoid self-incrimination. If the person suing you is someone who works with or for you, you must not talk to them about the case and it is best practice to have a lawyer present.
Check your business insurance cover
Next, check your business insurance policy to see if it covers lawsuits and inform your insurer of the legal action. The policy may cover lawyer fees, court costs or any settlement that you make which could save your business money. Markel Direct has a breakdown of what Professional Indemnity Insurance is, why you business might need it and how you can claim.
Next, gather any information that you have on this lawsuit (previous informal attempts to resolve, communication with the plaintiff) together so that you can prepare your response. It is important not to discard any information. Holland & Knight Law have created a PDF setting out how to collect and preserve relevant evidence.
Once you’ve done all of the above, it’s time to prepare your response. Make sure to act within the timescale set in the lawsuit. Lawyers.com have created a step-by-step guide for the lawsuit process.
In your response, address each allegation separately and state whether you agree or disagree with them. This is the time to provide any defences or counterclaims to the allegations. At the end of your response, provide some possible outcomes such as an out-of-court settlement. It could cost your business more in terms of legal fees and company time to fight the case rather than settling so it’s important to weigh up that option.
If you run a small business, have you found yourself in this situation before?
*Image courtesy of Flickr under the Creative Commons License
By subscribing, you'll receive new blog updates by email and occasionally I might email you with any exciting news. I promise not to spam you and your details will never be passed on.