Forget the chicken or the egg. The age-old question people need an answer to is: “should I invest with debt?” Is it better to put off investing until you’ve cleared your debt, or should you invest as you pay off your debt?
When you have debt, it’s only natural to want to pay it off as quickly as you can. But if you ignore setting money aside or investing it in the interests of bringing your debt balance to zero, you can end up doing more harm than good in the long run. Here’s why and what you can do to make a plan to get out of debt and plan for the future at the same time.
Why Invest When You’re Still in Debt
There are a few reasons why investing when you still have debt is a good idea. One reason is something called opportunity cost. Opportunity cost is the difference between the return on one investment and the return on the investment or decision you made instead.
Let’s say you have a $10,000 student loan with a 4.0 interest rate. You pay $109 per month towards the loan. You also have a 401k from your employer, and your employer offers a dollar for dollar match. The average return on the 401k is about 8 percent per year. If you have an extra $200 to spare each month after your other bills are paid, should you invest it or put it towards your student loan?
In this case, the answer might be to invest. If you threw an extra $200 per month at your student loan, you’d pay less interest, and you’d end up paying the entire loan off in just a few years. All told, you’d save about $1,300 in interest.
But at the same time, your savings would be considerably less compared to what you’d stand to gain by putting that $200 in your 401k. If your employer matched the $200 monthly contribution, you’d get $2,400 in pretty much free money that first year — considerably more than the $1,300 you save by speeding up payments on your student loan.
Of course, this formula only works for low-interest debt. If you are paying off a credit card with an interest rate of more than 10 percent, it makes sense to put more of your extra income each month towards the debt. But you don’t have to ignore investing entirely.
Getting Your Debt on Track
Another thing worth considering when deciding whether to invest when you still have debt or not is how much debt you have and whether you feel it’s manageable or not. If you’ve gotten in over your head with debt, and debt collectors are calling you, you need to sort that out before you think about investing. One option is to check out the debt collection licensing for any collectors who are bugging you. They can’t harass you if they aren’t properly licensed.
Another thing to do is to make a list of your debts, the minimum or monthly payments and the interest rates on those debts. Include your credit card debt, student loan debt and car loans in this list, but leave out your mortgage. If your monthly debt payments are near 50 percent of your income (or more), making paying off debt a priority is often your best course of action.
If your debt is well below half of your income and the interest rates are low, or in the case of student loans, deductible, investing while paying off debt is a smart choice.
How to Get Started With Investing
Where do you get started when it comes to investing while you still have debt? A good place to start is with an investment fiduciary.
A fiduciary is a financial planner who’s required to put your interests first when it comes to making investment advice. Fiduciaries are ethically bound to put you first. It’s serious stuff, and it means that you can rest assured that any investment recommendations a fiduciary make are made with the intention of helping you build wealth, not helping the financial planner line their pockets.
A financial planner who’s a fiduciary can recommend investments that suit your level of risk tolerance and that don’t have hefty fees which eat into your eventual earnings.
Not every financial planner is a fiduciary, so it always pays to ask when you’re interviewing planners. Legally, a planner who isn’t a fiduciary can’t tell you that they are. When you’re looking for planners, you can look at how they charge. Fiduciaries are fee-based, meaning you pay them for their time. Non-fiduciary planners often collect a commission (in some cases on top of a fee) when they recommend certain investments. That can be a serious conflict of interest.
Everyone wants to get out of debt. But you don’t have to put your financial future on hold while you’re paying down yesterday’s financial decisions.